[It's clear that this is all very brand new to him and yet his eyes light up with something...that looks...weirdly like hope. It's the first sign of something positive for days and he laughs softly, like he can't believe this is real.]

I think...I might know your leader. [Oh gods what the fuck.] Came to me a few weeks ago because he thought I might be one of you, or that I might know of the others. And while that's flattering, that's unfortunately not the case. I was just as clueless as most of this town until Natalie told me about the roles at all.

He said..."I have to find someone. If I find them, the game will be over." The Sheriff wouldn't tell him who or what they were, but he had to find them. And kill them.

Sound about right for who your leader could be?